CD Brahms 2 TLS 2018
In particular, the recording shows that such arrangements had their own artistic value above and beyond any marketing strategy. In this way, Brahms, in his reduction of the orchestral texture, strove not for documentary accuracy, but for a clarity not possible in the larger setting. The interpretation of the Lucerne piano duo was consistent with this. Their sound is not souped up or smoothed over by studio technology, and the resulting transparency highlights with an incisive clarity the motivic connections so important in Brahms.
And so we hear the work afresh. Polyphonic entanglements are laid bare, lyrical melodies and dialogues between the voices in the second movement emerge all the more vividly from pianistic writing, and the bass retains its definition even in the low trills which imitate the timpani roll. The duo does not execute tutti surges with massive pomp, but with a tension in their sound suggestive of fullness and even of force. In the folk-inspired rhythmic outbursts in the third and fourth movements, their duet playing achieves a verve hardly to be attained with orchestral forces.
Urs Mattenberger